Saturday, December 27, 2008

The Apartment Pariah

I consider myself to be of the moderate-Left in Israeli politics.

To my consternation, my roommates asked me before hanging up an Israeli flag in the living room if it was all right. The Palestinian flag graces my desktop partly because it just looks so cool.

And I never understood how people could get so worked up over politics.

So much has happened today. This morning Israel attacked Gaza with air strikes killing more than 200 people and counting. As I read the paper, some part of my brain wondered what kind of retaliation this first attack would bring.

This afternoon, as I set out on my post-Shabbat dinner mandatory jog, I noticed plumes of black smoke near the Hebrew U campus. As it is on my usual route anyway, I figured I would run into the source sooner or later. I didn't think it was anything serious as cars zoomed past in their normal fashion and the usual few people strolled along the streets.

I didn't end up running into the source as it was further away than I had expected, but instead along the course of my jog, I kept hearing mini-explosion sounds coming from the east. Then I noticed through my headphones several sirens as police cars and ambulances rushed toward the Arab villages in East Jerusalem. I thought I was crazy as I looked around to gauge other people's reactions, but no one else seemed to be phased by it. Israelis. Then I saw another great plume of smoke coming from the Shuafat RC area as helicopters droned overhead. Something was definitely wrong.

My roommates and I frantically tried to get any news on what was going on as we realized this was Palestinians in the West Bank and East Jerusalem rioting in response to what had occurred in Gaza this morning. Unfortunately we don't have a t.v., and for some reason, there was and as I write this post, continues to be no news on what happened earlier tonight in Jerusalem.

As we all congregated in one of my roommate's rooms with our laptops propped open furiously checking all the news websites, I wondered aloud if most of the people killed in the Israeli attack were civilians or security personnel. One of my roommates matter-of-factly said "They were all security personnel." To which, I retorted, "That is most definitely not true. Civilians are dead."

-"Well, they [Palestinians] put their weapons in libraries, hospitals, schools, etc."

-"And Israel still struck them."

My other roommates looked a little shocked by my response as one explained that the majority of the dead were Hamas security while there were also civilian deaths. Then one by one, everyone filed out of the room, and soon I was left in an awkward silence with only the room's inhabitant. I got up and left too. As soon as I left, they all went back in and closed the door behind them.

Perhaps I was a little too abrupt-too aggressive. Maybe I could have been more diplomatic and tried to be funny about it. No, I couldn't have. People are dead-and these people include innocent men, women, and children. There's no use in playing the blame game I realize, and I'm not sure what exactly makes me so upset.

But this is not the point of the post.

My roommate and I don't even live here; we don't suffer the way Israelis and Palestinians suffer here on a daily basis from the occupation and from terrorism. Yet, we get so impassioned by the politics that embroil this city, this country, this region. I couldn't understand how Israelis and Palestinians in Jerusalem could live side-by-side everyday without really talking to each other. And now, I understand, sometimes it's just easier to walk away and ignore the other side than get into the politics.

7 comments:

ORS said...

i don't really have the words to express what i'm thinking right now after reading your post, just know it really touched me.

and i know everyone is probably telling you this, but please stay safe.

Slee said...

thanks orly. will do :)

iris said...

우리가 보는세상 그보여지는것 그것이 전부는 아니란다.이미 많은 사람들이 알고 있는 사실들을 굳이 쓰지 않을 뿐이란다. 용기가 없다고 말하지마라 그건 용기 이전에 우리가 함부로 말하지 않는 지혜라는것도 필요하니까 하지만 너의 울분과 슬픔은 충분히 가치있고 아름다운거란다. 아름다운 너의마음을 알릴수 있는 힘을 키우는것 그것이 너가 지금할수 있는 최선이겠지 . 하지만 그래서 너는 그곳에서 공부를 하는거고 배워가는 과정이 아니겠니. 지금은 너는 계속 듣고 보고 배운것을 정리해서 너의것으로 만들고 그러면서 힘을 기르는거겠지.
너또래의 많은 아이들이 겉으로 보여지는것, 향락, 편한것만을 추구하는데 더군다나 지금 이 들뜬 계절에,남의 아픔을 가슴 아파하고 불의에 몸을 떠는 너는 얼마나 아름다운 영혼의 소유자인지....그마음 영원히 변치 말아라. 사랑한다 딸아 그리고 아주 많이자랑스럽다

Unknown said...

hey ugly,

almost time for you to come home. it must be hard to be away from the fam during the holidays, and no worries, we all talked (good stuff) about you when you weren't here. at least you're coming home soon, and i'm sure you'll have time to absorb everything you've been through the past semester. and seriously, you've had quite an extreme life the past semester (*high five* great success!)

i read/heard what's going on over there, and the only thing i can really take from all this is to see how messed up people can be. during the "most wonderful time" of the year? REALLY!? the most f'ed up things always seem to happen around the times that are supposed to be the happiest. well, when bad shit goes down, the best thing to do is to keep your head down. be extra safe - 10 days (or so) til you're home. don't go places you know will have heat (i.e. open demonstrationg/protests/etc.) and don't let your personal/political beliefs and all that come between you and your roommates. you're right - it's not your fight, and it's good to feel *something* about it, but you're only there a little while longer and you shouldn't leave on bad terms. if they are reasonable people, then they will understand that it's ok to have two angles about the same thing, and that they (and you) should realize that shutting it down and being closed-minded about it is what's led us here in the first place (hasn't this been going on forever.)

하구 게내들 진짜 못떼개 구르면, 좃까라가 그래두데구. ^^

stay safe, and we'll hang out soon.

-your brother

p.s. 엄아's comment musta taken forever for you to read/translate. haha.

TiffJung said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
TiffJung said...

wow, what a crazy day. i'd have to agree completely with you, but maybe its because i'm biased towards you, i dont know. maybe not. innocent civilians are always hurt, no matter what side is doing the attacking and no matter who is right or wrong. someone always gets hurt. even if security personnel were the only people killed in the israeli attack, those security personnel are still people. they have families who care about them, they all have mothers who worry about them. security personnel, civilians, bystanders ... they're all the same, they're all people who someone cares about. no one is every truly innocent in any violent attack. just because you kill security personnel doesn't make you any better than killing innocent civilians (does it? i don't see how differentiating makes it any different. the differentiation between the two seems so PC to me). people just have to accept the wrong that is committed on both sides. that is, people do shitty things. they have their reasons. whether you agree with them or not, the shit happens. i totally see how israelis and palestinians could walk away and ignore each other rather than continue arguing about something that just doesn't seem to have a solution.

huh, how pessimistic.

Jeni said...

haha wow i feel too inadequately informed about the israeli/palestinian conflict to attempt any sort of intellectual comment, but all i want to say is i hope you're safe and happy wherever you are at the moment. the news coverage is bleak at best, and cnn is, as always, making it as sensational as possible. not that it isn't a sensational story, but really, it's times like these that i wish i got bbc or al jazeera. i can't wait for you to come home so that i can get a first hand account of all this - it's really strange to see pro-/anti- israeli demonstrations here in LA and realize that you're really out there amidst the action. miss you so much, please please take paul's advice and "keep your head down." can't wait to see you back home.